Project

General

Profile

Repo Protocol Specification » History » Version 64

Shuo Chen, 02/24/2014 02:31 PM

1 1 Shuo Chen
Repo Protocol Specification
2
===========================
3
4 36 Shuo Chen
A Repo supports the network by preserving content and responding to Interests requesting content that it holds. A Repo can exist in any node, and is recommended if applications in that node need to preserve data. The NDN repo protocol is a specification of repo operations including reading, insertion and deletion of data objects in repo.
5 2 Shuo Chen
6
Repo semantics is based on [Command Interests](http://redmine.named-data.net/projects/nfd/wiki/Command_Interests) with signed commponents an the end of the name and basic common semantics of NDN. 
7
8 11 Shuo Chen
When some operation of repo including insertion and deletion of data objects is requested, a command interest is sent. The command interest is the interest as command of insertion and deletion and signed as form of command interest for access control. The repo will response the command with the data object.
9 4 Shuo Chen
10
The repo protocol can be categorized in three sections of reading, insertion and deletion of data objects.
11
12
## Repo Reading Specification
13
14 36 Shuo Chen
Repo registers prefixes of data objects it holds into NDN fowarding deamon and the repo will respond the data with such prefixes.
15 6 Shuo Chen
16 11 Shuo Chen
A standard interest is used to fetch content from the repo. The repo will respond when the name of the interest matches the prefix it registered in NFD. If the content in repo matches the interests, it will respond with the data object. When the interest is not matched, it will not respond.
17 6 Shuo Chen
18
The protocol is listed as bellow
19
20
If there is a matching data object:
21
22 7 Shuo Chen
    Requester                     Repo
23
        |                           |
24
        |                           |
25
        |         Interest          |
26
     t1 |-------------------------->|
27
        |                           |
28
        |        Data Object        |
29
     t2 |<==========================|
30 1 Shuo Chen
        |                           |
31 7 Shuo Chen
        |                           |
32 1 Shuo Chen
        |                           |
33 7 Shuo Chen
34
If there is no matching data object:
35 6 Shuo Chen
36
    Requester                     Repo
37
        |                           |
38 1 Shuo Chen
        |                           |
39 7 Shuo Chen
        |         Interest          |
40
     t1 |-------------------------->|
41
        |                           |
42
        |                           |
43
        |                           |
44
45 30 Shuo Chen
## Repo Command
46
For insertion, deletion and other operations of repo, these commands are encoded in the form of [sigend command interest](http://redmine.named-data.net/projects/nfd/wiki/Command_Interests). The semantics of repo command interest is as follows:
47 14 Shuo Chen
48 8 Shuo Chen
The name semantics is defined to have following components:
49 1 Shuo Chen
50 17 Shuo Chen
* ``<name of repo>`` refers to specific name of repo
51 30 Shuo Chen
* ``<command verb>`` refers to the name of command
52
* ``<RepoCommandParameters>`` refers to parameters of repo command
53 1 Shuo Chen
54 38 Shuo Chen
The following components are components of singed interest for access control:
55 1 Shuo Chen
56
* ``<timestamp>``
57 8 Shuo Chen
* ``<random-value>``
58
* ``<SignatureInfo>``
59
* ``<SignatureValue>``
60
61 30 Shuo Chen
For name of the repo /ucla/cs/repo/, the command will be defined as this:
62 33 Shuo Chen
63 30 Shuo Chen
    /ucla/cs/repo/<command verb>/<RepoCommandParameters>/<timestamp>/<random-value>/<SignatureInfo>/<SignatureValue>
64 14 Shuo Chen
65 30 Shuo Chen
### RepoCommandParameters
66 29 Shuo Chen
67 48 Shuo Chen
    RepoCommandParameters ::= REPOCOMMANDPARAMETERS-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
68 1 Shuo Chen
                               Name?
69 42 Shuo Chen
                               Selectors?
70 1 Shuo Chen
                               StartBlockId?
71
                               EndBlockId?
72 62 Shuo Chen
                               ProcessId?
73 29 Shuo Chen
74 48 Shuo Chen
    Name                  ::= NAME-TYPE TLV-LENGTH NameComponent*
75
    NameComponent         ::= NAME-COMPONENT-TYPE TLV-LENGTH BYTE+
76 43 Shuo Chen
77
    Selectors             ::= SELECTORS-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
78
                               MinSuffixComponents?
79
                               MaxSuffixComponents?
80
                               PublisherPublicKeyLocator?
81
                               Exclude?
82 47 Shuo Chen
                               ChildSelector?
83 43 Shuo Chen
84
    MinSuffixComponents   ::= MIN-SUFFIX-COMPONENTS-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
85
                               nonNegativeInteger
86
87
    MaxSuffixComponents   ::= MAX-SUFFIX-COMPONENTS-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
88
                               nonNegativeInteger
89
90
    PublisherPublicKeyLocator ::= KeyLocator
91
92
    Exclude               ::= EXCLUDE-TYPE TLV-LENGTH Any? (NameComponent (Any)?)+
93
    Any                   ::= ANY-TYPE TLV-LENGTH(=0)
94 47 Shuo Chen
95
    ChildSelector         ::= CHILD-SELECTOR-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
96
                               nonNegativeInteger
97 1 Shuo Chen
    
98
    StartBlockId          ::= STARTBLOCKID-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
99 49 Shuo Chen
                               nonNegativeInteger
100 1 Shuo Chen
    
101
    EndBlockId            ::= ENDBLOCKID-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
102 49 Shuo Chen
                               nonNegativeInteger
103 1 Shuo Chen
104 62 Shuo Chen
    ProcessId            ::= PROCESSID-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
105
                               nonNegativeInteger
106
107 45 Shuo Chen
#### Name
108
109 50 Shuo Chen
Name in command parameter is TLV-encoded block and represents the name or prefix of the data repo will process. The definition and format of name section are the same as the [name section](http://named-data.net/doc/ndn-tlv/name.html#name) of NDN interest.
110 45 Shuo Chen
111 44 Shuo Chen
#### Repo Command Selectors
112 38 Shuo Chen
113 52 Shuo Chen
Repo command supports parts of interest selectors of interest to indicate which contents to process. The definition of standard NDN selectors is described in [NDN Selectors Doc](http://named-data.net/doc/ndn-tlv/interest.html#selectors). The concrete definitions of both standard NDN selectors and repo command selectors are the same.
114
115
The difference between standard NDN interest and Repo Deletion Command interest that, the standard NDN selectors just matches **one** data packet that conforms to the selector conditions, but repo command selectors would matches **any** data packets. For example, if Interest is expressed for /ndn/edu and Exclude specifies one name component ucla, in standard NDN interest, the data producers will first exclude all the data packets with prefix /ndn/edu but not /ndn/edu/ucla, and then just selects one data packet. In repo deletion command interest, it will select all the data packets with prefix /ndn/edu but not /ndn/edu/ucla. However, in repo insert command, the repo will fetch one data just like standard interest selectors.
116 38 Shuo Chen
117 51 Shuo Chen
Repo command supports parts of standard NDN interests including MinSuffixComponents, MaxSuffixComponents, PublisherPublicKeyLocator, Exclude, ChildSelector. If command contains other selectors, repo will ignore these not supported selectors. In addition, selectors are just supported in delete command. If other commands contains selectors, repo will ignore selectors when processing these commands.
118 38 Shuo Chen
119
The form of selectors is as follows:
120
121
    Selectors             ::= SELECTORS-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
122
                               MinSuffixComponents?
123
                               MaxSuffixComponents?
124
                               PublisherPublicKeyLocator?
125 1 Shuo Chen
                               Exclude?
126 51 Shuo Chen
                               ChildSelector?
127 38 Shuo Chen
    
128
    MinSuffixComponents   ::= MIN-SUFFIX-COMPONENTS-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
129
                               nonNegativeInteger
130
131
    MaxSuffixComponents   ::= MAX-SUFFIX-COMPONENTS-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
132
                               nonNegativeInteger
133
134
    PublisherPublicKeyLocator ::= KeyLocator
135
    
136
    Exclude               ::= EXCLUDE-TYPE TLV-LENGTH Any? (NameComponent (Any)?)+
137 1 Shuo Chen
    Any                   ::= ANY-TYPE TLV-LENGTH(=0)
138 51 Shuo Chen
139
    ChildSelector         ::= CHILD-SELECTOR-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
140
                               nonNegativeInteger
141 46 Shuo Chen
142
#### StartBlockId, EndBlockId
143 38 Shuo Chen
144 54 Shuo Chen
StartBlockId and EndBlockId are used to process segmented data. StartBlockId indicate the first segment number and EndBlockId indicate the last segment number. Repo will process segment data whose segment id between StartBlockId and EndBlockId. If StartBlockId is missing, the first segment id the repo process is 0; If EndBlockId is missing, this scenario is described in specific process in Repo Insertion Command section and Repo Deletion Command section.
145 62 Shuo Chen
146
#### ProcessId
147 53 Shuo Chen
148 63 Shuo Chen
ProcessId is used by insertion and deletion check command to indicate specific insertion and deletion process. The ProcessId is fetched by repo command response of insertion and deletion command.
149
150 30 Shuo Chen
## Repo Command Response
151 1 Shuo Chen
152 30 Shuo Chen
Repo command response is the response data packet of repo command interest. The response contains statuscode to indicate the status of command process and other information. A TLV-encoded block called ``RepoCommandResponse`` is encoded in content of the data packet.
153 1 Shuo Chen
154 30 Shuo Chen
    RepoCommandResponse   ::= INSERTSTATUS-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
155 61 Shuo Chen
                               ProcessId?
156 1 Shuo Chen
                               StatusCode?
157
                               StartBlockId?
158
                               EndBlockId?
159
                               InsertNum?
160 30 Shuo Chen
                               DeleteNum?
161 1 Shuo Chen
162 61 Shuo Chen
    ProcessId            ::= PROCESSID-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
163 55 Shuo Chen
                                nonNegativeInteger 
164
    
165 1 Shuo Chen
    StatusCode            ::= STATUSCODE-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
166
                                nonNegativeInteger    
167
168
    StartBlockId          ::= STARTBLOCKID-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
169
                                nonNegativeInteger
170
    
171
    EndBlockId            ::= ENDBLOCKID-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
172
                                nonNegativeInteger
173 17 Shuo Chen
174
    InsertNum             ::= INSERTNUM-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
175
                                nonNegativeInteger
176
177 30 Shuo Chen
    DeleteNum             ::= DELETENUM-TYPE TLV-LENGTH
178
                                nonNegativeInteger
179 17 Shuo Chen
180 61 Shuo Chen
### ProcessId
181
ProcessId is a random number generated by repo to indicate the number of the command process. Client could use this ProcessId to check the status of specific command.
182 59 Shuo Chen
183
### StatusCode
184
185 64 Shuo Chen
StatusCode indicates the status of repo command process. The statuscodes of insert and deletion command are described in following insertion and deletion specification.
186
187 59 Shuo Chen
### StartBlockId, EndBlockId
188
189
### InsertNum, DeleteNum
190
191 58 Shuo Chen
## Repo Trust Model
192 57 Shuo Chen
193
The trust model of repo depends on people who deploy the repo service, such as PKI. Repo can specify their own verification policies, and data consumers can specify their own trust anchors. The NDN [FAQ](http://named-data.net/project/faq/#How_does_NDN8217s_8220trust_management8221_work) shows how NDN trust managment works.
194
195 30 Shuo Chen
## Repo Insertion Specification
196
197
Insertion specification is for some client and application to insert data objects into certain NDN repo. A command interest as insertion command will be sent to the repo. This command interest is a signed interest and will be validated with access control policy defined by the repo. When the interested is validated and name of the data is not existed in the repo. The repository will reponse with a data object containing OK status and start to send the interest to fetch the data to insert.
198
199
Segmented data insertion is also supported in the insertion protocol. Segmantation info is defined as a TLV-encoded SegmantationInfo block. If the content is segmented, the final segment id will be encoded in this block.
200
201
### Insertion command interest semantics
202
203
The name semantics is follows the format of the repo command. The <command verb> is defined as ``insert``.
204
For example, for ``<name of repo>`` as ``/ucla/cs/repo``, the following is an example:
205 1 Shuo Chen
206 31 Shuo Chen
    /ucla/cs/repo/insert/<RepoCommandParameters>/<timestamp>/<random-value>/<SignatureInfo>/<SignatureValue>
207 30 Shuo Chen
208
### Insertion status check
209
210
During the insertion progress, the requester could send insertion status check command to check the status of the insertion progress. This status check command is also signed interest. The semantics of insertion status check command is shown as follows:
211
212
<command verb> equals to ``insert check``. For example:
213 1 Shuo Chen
214 32 Shuo Chen
    /ucla/cs/repo/insert check/<RepoCommandParameters>/<timestamp>/<random-value>/<SignatureInfo>/<SignatureValue>
215 30 Shuo Chen
216 40 Shuo Chen
### Insert and Insert check command seletors
217
218
Selectors are not supported in these commands. Repo will ignore selectors when processing these commands.
219
220 30 Shuo Chen
### Insertatation status response
221
222
This insert status data object could be the response data object of both insert command and insert check command. It will follow the format of repo command response.
223
224
StatusCode indicates the status of insertion. InsertNum represents how many data has been intersted into the repo. StartBlockId and EndBlockId is the start and end segment id of data inserted. InsertNum is the how many data segments have been inserted.
225
226
For insert cammand, status code will be set according to definition below, StartBlockId and EndBlockId will be set according to the insert command.
227
228
For insert check command, status code will be set according to definition below, StartBlockId and EndBlockId will be set according to the insert command, insertnum will be set according to insertion progress.
229
230 1 Shuo Chen
StatusCode Definition:
231 17 Shuo Chen
232
``StatusCode`` | Description
233
-------------- | ----------------------------------------------
234 19 Shuo Chen
``100``        | The command is OK. can start to fetch the data
235
``200``        | All the data has been inserted
236 17 Shuo Chen
``300``        | This insertion is in progress
237
``401``        | This insertion check is invalidated
238
``404``        | No such this insertion is in progress
239 30 Shuo Chen
``505``        | status check command is not supported
240 17 Shuo Chen
241 22 Alex Afanasyev
### Protocol Process
242
243 20 Alex Afanasyev
1. start to authorize the command; if authorization does not fail immediately, go to step 3
244 17 Shuo Chen
245 20 Alex Afanasyev
2. send a negative response indicating authorization failure, and abort these steps
246 14 Shuo Chen
247 20 Alex Afanasyev
3. if both StartBlockId and EndBlockId are missing, go to step 6
248 14 Shuo Chen
249 20 Alex Afanasyev
4. if both StartBlockId and EndBlockId are present, and StartBlockId is less than or equal to EndBlockId, go to step 6
250 14 Shuo Chen
251 20 Alex Afanasyev
5. send a negative response indicating malformed command, and abort these steps
252 14 Shuo Chen
253 20 Alex Afanasyev
6. wait for authorization completion
254 14 Shuo Chen
255 20 Alex Afanasyev
7. if authorization fails, go to step 2
256 14 Shuo Chen
257 20 Alex Afanasyev
8. send a positive response indicating insert is in progress
258 14 Shuo Chen
259 20 Alex Afanasyev
9. if both StartBlockId and EndBlockId are present, go to step 15
260 14 Shuo Chen
261 20 Alex Afanasyev
10. start to retrieve Name
262 14 Shuo Chen
263 20 Alex Afanasyev
11. wait for retrieval completion
264 14 Shuo Chen
265 20 Alex Afanasyev
12. if retrieval fails, abort these steps
266 14 Shuo Chen
267 20 Alex Afanasyev
13. store retrieved Data packet
268 14 Shuo Chen
269 20 Alex Afanasyev
14. abort these steps
270 14 Shuo Chen
271 20 Alex Afanasyev
15. append StartBlockId to Name
272 1 Shuo Chen
273 20 Alex Afanasyev
16. start to retrieve Name
274 14 Shuo Chen
275 20 Alex Afanasyev
17. wait for retrieval completion
276 14 Shuo Chen
277 20 Alex Afanasyev
18. if retrieval fails, abort these steps
278 14 Shuo Chen
279 20 Alex Afanasyev
19. store retrieved Data packet
280 15 Shuo Chen
281 20 Alex Afanasyev
20. if retrieved Data packet contains FinalBlockId, and FinalBlockId is less than EndBlockId, let EndBlockId be FinalBlockId
282 15 Shuo Chen
283 20 Alex Afanasyev
21. if the last component of Name is greater than or equal to EndBlockId, abort these steps
284 15 Shuo Chen
285 20 Alex Afanasyev
22. increment the last component of Name
286 15 Shuo Chen
287 20 Alex Afanasyev
23. go to step 16
288 15 Shuo Chen
289 20 Alex Afanasyev
Implementation MAY pipeline the Interests.
290 1 Shuo Chen
291 20 Alex Afanasyev
### Repo command progress report
292 16 Shuo Chen
293 20 Alex Afanasyev
Implementation MAY publish a notification of status regarding insert progress. The process of status check is as follows:
294 18 Shuo Chen
295 20 Alex Afanasyev
1. start to authorize the insert status command
296 1 Shuo Chen
297 20 Alex Afanasyev
2. send a negative response indicating authorization failure, and abort these steps
298 18 Shuo Chen
299 20 Alex Afanasyev
3. start to check the progress of the insert with the data name in the command. If no such progress is found, go to 4. or go to 5.
300 18 Shuo Chen
301 20 Alex Afanasyev
4. reponse status with status code of 404
302 18 Shuo Chen
303 20 Alex Afanasyev
5. ckeck te status of insertion. return the status data content
304
305 17 Shuo Chen
### Protocol diagram:
306 10 Alex Afanasyev
307
    Requester                     Repo                          Data producer
308
        |                           |                                 |
309
        |                           |                                 |
310
      +---+  Insert command       +---+                               |
311
      |   | --------------------> |   |                               |
312
      +---+                       |   |                               |
313
        |                         |   |                               |
314
      +---+   Confirm start       |   |                               |
315
      |   | <==================== |   |                               |
316
      +---+   Reject command      +---+                               |
317
        |     (with status code)    |                                 |
318
        |                         +---+     Interest for Data       +---+
319 1 Shuo Chen
        |                         |   | --------------------------> |   |
320
        |                         +---+                             |   |
321 10 Alex Afanasyev
        |                           |                               |   |
322
        |                         +---+       Data segment          |   |
323
        |                         |   | <========================== |   |
324
        |                         +---+                             +---+
325
        |                           |                                 |
326
        |                           ~                                 ~
327
        |                           ~                                 ~
328
        |                           |                                 |
329
        |                         +---+     Interest for Data       +---+
330
        |                         |   | --------------------------> |   |
331
        |                         +---+                             |   |
332 1 Shuo Chen
        |                           |                               |   |
333
        |                         +---+       Data segment          |   |
334
        |                         |   | <========================== |   |
335
        |                         +---+                             +---+
336
        |                           |                                 |
337
        |                           |                                 |
338 17 Shuo Chen
        |                           ~                                 ~
339 1 Shuo Chen
        |                           ~                                 ~
340
        |                           |                                 |
341 30 Shuo Chen
        |                           |                                 |
342 19 Shuo Chen
        |                           |                                 |
343 30 Shuo Chen
      +---+   Status interest     +---+                               |
344 19 Shuo Chen
      |   | --------------------> |   |                               |
345
      +---+                       |   |                               |
346
        |                         |   |                               |
347
      +---+    Status response    |   |                               |
348
      |   | <==================== |   |                               |
349
      +---+                       +---+                               |
350
        |                           |                                 |
351
        |                           |                                 |
352
353
## Repo Deletion Specification
354
355
Deletion of one content object or content objects under certain prefix are both supported in repo specification. Selectors are used to select multiple content objects. These selectors are different from conventional [selectors](http://named-data.net/doc/ndn-tlv/interest.html#selectors) of interest packet. The conventional selecors of interest would select one data packet of repo. Selecors of delete command will return any data packets which applies for these selectors.
356
357
### Deletion command interest semantics
358
359 1 Shuo Chen
Deletion command interest follows the format of the repo command. For example:
360 19 Shuo Chen
361
    /ucla/cs/repo/delete/<RepoCommandParameters>/<timestamp>/<random-value>/<SignatureInfo>/<SignatureValue>
362
363
### Deletion Command Selectors
364
365 39 Shuo Chen
Deletion command selectors follows the [repo command selectors](http://redmine.named-data.net/projects/repo-ng/wiki/Repo_Protocol_Specification#Repo-Command-Selectors).
366
367 19 Shuo Chen
### Deletion status check
368
369 30 Shuo Chen
During the deletion progress, the requester could send deletion status check command to check the status of the deletion progress. This status check command is also signed interest. The semantics of deletion status check command follows the format of repo command. ``<command verb>`` equals to ``delete check``. For example:
370 1 Shuo Chen
371 34 Shuo Chen
    /ucla/cs/repo/delete/<RepoCommandParameters>/<timestamp>/<random-value>/<SignatureInfo>/<SignatureValue>
372 19 Shuo Chen
373 41 Shuo Chen
### Deletion Check Command Selectors
374
375
Selectors are not supported. Repo will ignore selectors when processing deletion status check command.
376
377 19 Shuo Chen
### Deletion status response
378
379 30 Shuo Chen
This delete status data object could be the response data packet of both delete command and delete check command. The name of data packet is the same as that of command.The deletion status is enocoded as a TLV echoded block in content block in data packet. The TLV block format follows RepoCommandResponse.
380 19 Shuo Chen
381
StatusCode indicates the status of deletion. DeleteSum is the sum of the deletion. DeleteNum represents how many data has been deleted.
382
383
StatusCode Definition:
384
385
``StatusCode`` | Description
386
-------------- | --------------------------------------
387
``200``        | All the data has been deleted
388
``300``        | This deletion is in progress
389
``401``        | This deletion check is invalidated
390
``404``        | No such this deletion is in progress
391 30 Shuo Chen
``505``        | status check command is not supported
392 19 Shuo Chen
393 17 Shuo Chen
### Protocol process
394 1 Shuo Chen
395 21 Alex Afanasyev
1. start to authorize the command; if authorization does not fail immediately, go to step 3
396 1 Shuo Chen
397 21 Alex Afanasyev
2. send a negative response indicating authorization failure, and abort these steps
398 1 Shuo Chen
399 21 Alex Afanasyev
3. check whether selectors are presented. If selectors are presented, go to step 4, or select the data packet of the exact name of command. If some data is selected, go to step 6. If no data selected, go to step 5
400 1 Shuo Chen
401 21 Alex Afanasyev
4. select all the data packets that comforms to data name of the command and the selectors. If some data packets are selected, go to step 6. Or no data selected, go to step 5.
402 1 Shuo Chen
403 21 Alex Afanasyev
5. send a negative response and abort the delete transaction.
404 1 Shuo Chen
405 21 Alex Afanasyev
6. wait for authorization completion
406 1 Shuo Chen
407 21 Alex Afanasyev
7. if authorization fails, go to step 2
408 1 Shuo Chen
409 21 Alex Afanasyev
8. start to delete the selected data. If deletion success, return positive reponse, or return negative response and abort the deletion.
410 19 Shuo Chen
411 21 Alex Afanasyev
Implementation MAY publish a notification of status regarding delete progress. The process of status check is as follows:
412 19 Shuo Chen
413 21 Alex Afanasyev
1. start to authorize the delete status command
414 19 Shuo Chen
415 21 Alex Afanasyev
2. send a negative response indicating authorization failure, and abort these steps
416 19 Shuo Chen
417 21 Alex Afanasyev
3. start to check the progress of the delete with the data name in the command. If no such progress is found, go to 4. or go to 5.
418 19 Shuo Chen
419 21 Alex Afanasyev
4. reponse status with status code of 404
420
421
5. ckeck te status of delete. return the status data content
422 19 Shuo Chen
423
### Protocol diagram:
424
425
    Requester                     Repo 
426
        |                           |                                 
427
        |                           |                                 
428
      +---+  Delete command       +---+                               
429
      |   | --------------------> |   |                               
430
      +---+                       +---+                               
431
        |                           |                                 
432
        |                           |                                 
433
        |                           |                                 
434
      +---+   Status interest     +---+                               
435
      |   | --------------------> |   |                               
436
      +---+                       |   |                               
437
        |                         |   |                               
438
      +---+    Status response    |   |                               
439
      |   | <==================== |   |                               
440
      +---+                       +---+                               
441
        |                           |                                 
442
        |                           |                                 
443
        |                           |                                 
444
      +---+   Confirm Deletion    +---+                               
445
      |   | <==================== |   |                               
446
      +---+   Reject command      +---+                               
447
        |     (with status code)    |    
448 20 Alex Afanasyev
        |                           |