Bug #4980
closed
Duplicate nonce generation on retransmitted interests
0%
Description
I am running NDN on top of NFD 0.6.2. On the consumer end, I have the same interface drop packets/connection with NACK duplicate messages. On further investigation, I figured that some of the interests with interrupted connections generate "same" nonce for same interest packets (probably retransmitted) and whenever that happens, the connection over NFD completely drops.
I came across this conversation thread on issues/3888 on redmine and found that this was a design flaw that was to be corrected in v0.6 but I still see this in 0.6.2.
I have attached the ndndump trace file where you can trace the duplicate interests and how the NFD connection drops after it.
Could someone help me with this?
Files
| trace0 (47.2 KB) trace0 | ndndump trace from the interface that suddenly drops the NFD connection while file download. Cause: Duplicate nonce generated for retransmitted interest | ||
| tcpdump6 (40 KB) tcpdump6 | tcpdump over udp port 6363 | ||
| ndndump6 (48.2 KB) ndndump6 | ndndump over same interface as tcpdump | ||
| nfd.log (7.07 KB) nfd.log | default nfd log | ||
| ndnperf.png (14.6 KB) ndnperf.png |
Updated by Davide Pesavento over 4 years ago
- Tags deleted (
duplicate nonce) - Subject changed from Duplicate nonce generation on retrasnmitted interests to Duplicate nonce generation on retransmitted interests
- Category changed from Build to Forwarding
- Priority changed from Urgent to Normal
- Start date deleted (
08/14/2019)
Updated by Junxiao Shi over 4 years ago
Additional information is required to diagnose this issue:
Capture packet traces with tcpdump using filter "udp port 6363", not
ndndump.Provide NFD logs of the node where Nack packets originate. Set log levels as follows:
default_level INFO Forwarder TRACEExplain what makes you believe "the connection over NFD completely drops", and provide relevant logs to prove your claim.
See also: HOWTO write a bug report effectively.
Please provide requested information within 15 days.
Updated by Ishita Dasgupta over 4 years ago
- File tcpdump6 tcpdump6 added
- File ndndump6 ndndump6 added
- File nfd.log nfd.log added
- File ndnperf.png ndnperf.png added
Hi,
Here is the tcpdump log as you asked. I couldn't make sense of it as it doesn't say anything about the nack-ed packets (or I may have missed). I have attached the ndndump log for the same session if you need to compare/ for more information.
I am providing the default NFD log. I couldn't get the log with the FORWARDING trace on. (These nodes are containers that run nfd 0.6.1 and somehow "nfd-stop" doesn't run with error "command not found" even though I can see it. Thus, I am unable to modify the nfd.conf and restart the nfd daemon -- I am working on getting this fixed so that we can have more information)
I also noticed that other nodes that interact with these containers have NFD-0.6.2 so I'm trying to get them all working on the same version.
Apologies for saying that "the connection over NFD completely drops", I meant the ndnperf drops with a nack message. To give more backgorund, I am trying to download the same file on multiple containers hosted on the same node via ndnperf. And ndnperf on one of these containers nack-s while the file is not completely downloaded. And NDNPerf log and ndndump log led me to the duplicate nonce generation.
I am downloading NFD from https://github.com/named-data/NFD on to these containers that run Ubuntu 18.04, gcc version 7.4.0.
PS: As soon, as I can restart the nfd daemon on this containers, I will update the NFD log trace.
Updated by Junxiao Shi over 4 years ago
Here is the tcpdump log as you asked.
It's not captured correctly. Use -w flag to generate .pcap files. stdout is useless.
I couldn't get the log with the FORWARDING trace on.
Then it's useless.
I meant the ndnperf drops with a nack message.
Report a bug on ndnperf issue tracker, as they are not handling Nack properly.
It's not NFD closing the face.
Updated by Junxiao Shi over 4 years ago
- Status changed from New to Rejected
I meant the ndnperf drops with a nack message.
Report a bug on ndnperf issue tracker, as they are not handling Nack properly.
Reported as ndnperf issue 1.
I'm rejecting this bug because this is not an NFD bug, but an ndnperf bug.
If there's additional log files that indicate an NFD bug, please still upload them. I'll reopen this issue when they are uploaded.